Fair applied the “Page 99 Test” to his new book, Mr. America: The Tragic History of a Bodybuilding Icon, and reported the following:
Page 99 [inset below left; click to enlarge] is fairly representative of the subject matter and my writing style. It includes a Harry Paschall cartoon which is revealing about how some people felt about Mr. America and bodybuilders in general. Readers might find it amusing.Learn more about Mr. America: The Tragic History of a Bodybuilding Icon at the University of Texas Press website.
What the page doesn't include is any interpretive content which is an important part of the book. In this respect the book uses bodybuilding to reflect on the decline of American idealism and how the decline of the Mr. America reflected the changing culture of the times. The decline of Americanism is merely part of the larger process of a questioning of western values that are rooted in the so-called Greek ideal which became an American ideal. This process is particularly evident in bodybuilding at least since the Chicago World’s Fair in 1893 and the inception of the Olympics in 1896, and in 1939 the Greek ideal of mens sana in corpore sano became the Mr. America ideal. It was also reflected in depictions of American womanhood with the inception of the Miss America Contest in 1921 which served as a template for Mr. America. The thesis of the book is reflected in the dust cover picture of Steve Reeves (the choice of most bodybuilding buffs as the ideal Mr. America) posing as Myron’s Discobolos, the most famous Greek sculpture depicting the athletic ideal. Most revealing to me were my researches into the impact of Greek cultural values through Germany and Great Britain that informed how Americans viewed their bodies and society, at least until the late 1960s. I think my book helps inform the reading public how Mr. America symbolized a departure from those ideals and the extent to which a desire still exists for their return. Nowadays, however, few people understand this Greek connection to what we were and potentially what we hope to be. These ideas slowly unfolded over at least a decade while I engaged in full-time teaching and administrative work, writing articles on other subjects, seeking sources throughout the country, training and competing regularly, and maintaining a family life.
Writers Read: John D. Fair.