Monday, November 16, 2026

Jack Lule's "Persecuted: Why We Need Scapegoats"

Jack Lule is professor emeritus in the Department of Journalism and Communication at Lehigh University. His books include Globalization and Media: Global Village of Babel and Daily News, Eternal Stories: The Mythological Role of Journalism.

He applied the “Page 99 Test” to his new book, Persecuted: Why We Need Scapegoats, and reported the following:
I was a bit skeptical of the Page 99 Test – but it works! Page 99 is in the middle of a chapter called, “Nationalism and Racism.” The page is discussing the great British social theorist Stuart Hall. Hall was from the former British colony of Jamaica. He was a black man who found that Britian, his adopted home country, was gradually being changed by globalization.

Hall said that globalization was “destabilizing” white identities in Britain. He raised a question he said once was “literally unthinkable” – “Is it possible to be black and British?”

He then noted, “What is interesting here is that, in different ways and despite the specificities of the British case, we are witnessing a similar and parallel phenomenon in all the Western nation-states as a consequence of globalization.”

Hall wrote he was actually surprised that the “imagined community” of the nation had held up so well. He said, “It is striking to note that such versions of ‘imagined community,’ in Benedict Anderson’s sense, have largely remained intact until recently, since the nostalgia for community, for shared culture, is one of modernity’s consistently compensatory and consoling refrains.”

Page 99 works because the task of Persecuted is to bring together the thoughts of essential but challenging scholars to explain plainly our divided world today.

“Nationalism and Racism” is a key chapter. If we are looking at our divided and polarized world today, nationalism and racism are key. And if we are talking about nationalism and racism, Stuart Hall is key.

Hall wrote “Ethnicity and Difference” in 1989. He was able to see even then that a “nostalgia for community, for shared culture” would be a result of globalization. This “nostalgia” indeed has destabilized white communities and given rise today to populist movements around the world.

Shrinking, white, Western populations give voice to that nostalgia and try desperately to hang onto what they believe is French, Italian or British. “Make America Great Again” gives voice to that nostalgia. And the scapegoating of racial and ethnic minorities in nation after nation gives voice to that nostalgia.

I wrote Persecuted because I believe that scapegoating has and will tear apart nations around the world. And I now have grandchildren. But can scapegoating be overcome?

It is sad to admit but scapegoating is why people come together and how people come together. People unite more fiercely in fear and hatred than in comfort and love.

In our time, nations rely on scapegoating to draw boundaries between “us” and “them” and are ultimately fracturing along polarized lines of grievance and blame. I hope that by understanding scapegoating, we might lessen its power. But I fear not.
Visit Jack Lule's website.

--Marshal Zeringue