
He applied the "Page 99 Test" to his new book, Nuclear Reactions: The Ongoing Politics of a Radioactive Waste Site, and reported the following:
Page 99 deals with one of the controversies that plagued the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant (WIPP) — the country's first deep underground burial site for waste generated from building nuclear bombs — a decade before its eventual opening in 1999: Revelations that brine water was entering the 2,150-foot-deep chambers through shafts drilled on the surface and through fissures in subterranean salt cavern walls.Learn more about Nuclear Reactions at the University of New Mexico Press website.
This page serves as sort of a microcosm of WIPP's broader history. That's because a concern came to light not because the federal government made it public, but because one of the project's critics did so. In this case, the critic was a University of New Mexico geologist with a long record of questioning whether WIPP's developers were emphasizing political expediency over science. He contended the moisture of the brine could corrode the steel waste drums and make it impossible to retrieve the castoff materials inside (which, at the time, was a necessary requirement of WIPP's plans).
The project's scientists found the geologist's concerns overstated and inaccurate. But an independent state scientific watchdog was not as certain. The result was a case of dueling science — something that made achieving consensus extraordinarily difficult. Such scientific duels would recur until the Environmental Protection Agency gave its formal consent to use WIPP to permanently bury waste — an approval that, at the time of the brine debate, was not being considered.
The central thesis of my book is that WIPP is a Cold War-era project that was developed and operated in a post-Cold War world. That meant that unlike Cold War nuclear projects that operated largely in secret, it had to navigate a complex bureaucratic maze in which safety was ill-defined and based on considerable projection and scientific guesswork. The furor over brine was an example of how a scientific debate could have potentially been hashed out, and perhaps resolved, before scientists began trading accusations publicly through the news media and raising questions in the public's mind about whether the government was sacrificing safety in any way.
--Marshal Zeringue






















