Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Chuck McCutcheon's "Nuclear Reactions"

Chuck McCutcheon is an editor and writer in Washington, D.C., and the author of books on climate change, Congress, political jargon and other subjects.

He applied the "Page 99 Test" to his new book, Nuclear Reactions: The Ongoing Politics of a Radioactive Waste Site, and reported the following:
Page 99 deals with one of the controversies that plagued the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant (WIPP) — the country's first deep underground burial site for waste generated from building nuclear bombs — a decade before its eventual opening in 1999: Revelations that brine water was entering the 2,150-foot-deep chambers through shafts drilled on the surface and through fissures in subterranean salt cavern walls.

This page serves as sort of a microcosm of WIPP's broader history. That's because a concern came to light not because the federal government made it public, but because one of the project's critics did so. In this case, the critic was a University of New Mexico geologist with a long record of questioning whether WIPP's developers were emphasizing political expediency over science. He contended the moisture of the brine could corrode the steel waste drums and make it impossible to retrieve the castoff materials inside (which, at the time, was a necessary requirement of WIPP's plans).

The project's scientists found the geologist's concerns overstated and inaccurate. But an independent state scientific watchdog was not as certain. The result was a case of dueling science — something that made achieving consensus extraordinarily difficult. Such scientific duels would recur until the Environmental Protection Agency gave its formal consent to use WIPP to permanently bury waste — an approval that, at the time of the brine debate, was not being considered.

The central thesis of my book is that WIPP is a Cold War-era project that was developed and operated in a post-Cold War world. That meant that unlike Cold War nuclear projects that operated largely in secret, it had to navigate a complex bureaucratic maze in which safety was ill-defined and based on considerable projection and scientific guesswork. The furor over brine was an example of how a scientific debate could have potentially been hashed out, and perhaps resolved, before scientists began trading accusations publicly through the news media and raising questions in the public's mind about whether the government was sacrificing safety in any way.
Learn more about Nuclear Reactions at the University of New Mexico Press website.

--Marshal Zeringue

Monday, November 16, 2026

Jack Lule's "Persecuted: Why We Need Scapegoats"

Jack Lule is professor emeritus in the Department of Journalism and Communication at Lehigh University. His books include Globalization and Media: Global Village of Babel and Daily News, Eternal Stories: The Mythological Role of Journalism.

He applied the “Page 99 Test” to his new book, Persecuted: Why We Need Scapegoats, and reported the following:
I was a bit skeptical of the Page 99 Test – but it works! Page 99 is in the middle of a chapter called, “Nationalism and Racism.” The page is discussing the great British social theorist Stuart Hall. Hall was from the former British colony of Jamaica. He was a black man who found that Britian, his adopted home country, was gradually being changed by globalization.

Hall said that globalization was “destabilizing” white identities in Britain. He raised a question he said once was “literally unthinkable” – “Is it possible to be black and British?”

He then noted, “What is interesting here is that, in different ways and despite the specificities of the British case, we are witnessing a similar and parallel phenomenon in all the Western nation-states as a consequence of globalization.”

Hall wrote he was actually surprised that the “imagined community” of the nation had held up so well. He said, “It is striking to note that such versions of ‘imagined community,’ in Benedict Anderson’s sense, have largely remained intact until recently, since the nostalgia for community, for shared culture, is one of modernity’s consistently compensatory and consoling refrains.”

Page 99 works because the task of Persecuted is to bring together the thoughts of essential but challenging scholars to explain plainly our divided world today.

“Nationalism and Racism” is a key chapter. If we are looking at our divided and polarized world today, nationalism and racism are key. And if we are talking about nationalism and racism, Stuart Hall is key.

Hall wrote “Ethnicity and Difference” in 1989. He was able to see even then that a “nostalgia for community, for shared culture” would be a result of globalization. This “nostalgia” indeed has destabilized white communities and given rise today to populist movements around the world.

Shrinking, white, Western populations give voice to that nostalgia and try desperately to hang onto what they believe is French, Italian or British. “Make America Great Again” gives voice to that nostalgia. And the scapegoating of racial and ethnic minorities in nation after nation gives voice to that nostalgia.

I wrote Persecuted because I believe that scapegoating has and will tear apart nations around the world. And I now have grandchildren. But can scapegoating be overcome?

It is sad to admit but scapegoating is why people come together and how people come together. People unite more fiercely in fear and hatred than in comfort and love.

In our time, nations rely on scapegoating to draw boundaries between “us” and “them” and are ultimately fracturing along polarized lines of grievance and blame. I hope that by understanding scapegoating, we might lessen its power. But I fear not.
Visit Jack Lule's website.

--Marshal Zeringue

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Diego Zambrano's "How Americans Enforce the Law"

Diego Zambrano is Professor of Law, the Associate Dean for Global Programs, and faculty director of the Neukom Center for the Rule of Law at Stanford Law School.

He applied the "Page 99 Test" to his new book, How Americans Enforce the Law, with the following results:
Page 99 is in the history part of the book. The book as a whole addresses the phenomenon of private enforcement—how Americans rely on private lawsuits to enforce a whole range of regulatory statutes. That is, Americans resolve regulatory problems by both empowering public agents and adding rights to sue to important legislation. Page 99 discusses the historical precedent for this form of governance—so called “common informers.” That page specifically addresses a possible confusion that readers may have about common informers and whether they filed suit or were merely tipsters. I do not think this page is exemplary of the whole book.

I think readers would only get a very limited idea of the whole work. So the Page 99 Test does not work that well.

The page is still interesting and important because it is addressing the key historical precedent for modern private enforcement. And it is making clear that filing suit is very different from just informing about legal violations. So I think it is necessary for a full understanding of the phenomenon.
Learn more about How Americans Enforce the Law at the Stanford University Press website.

--Marshal Zeringue

Friday, November 13, 2026

Jennifer A. Jordan's "Beer Ghosts"

Jennifer A. Jordan is professor of sociology, urban studies, and history at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee. She is the author of Structures of Memory: Understanding Urban Change in Berlin and Beyond and Edible Memory: The Lure of Heirloom Tomatoes and other Forgotten Foods. She lives in Milwaukee, where she and her husband grow hops in their backyard.

Jordan applied the “Page 99 Test” to her latest book, Beer Ghosts: In Search of Lost Hops and the Women Who Grew Them, and shared the following:
From page 99:
Profits on the family’s hops more than doubled from 1866 to 1867, when the household harvested an impressive 13,249 pounds and netted a rollicking $4,613, even after shelling out hundreds of dollars to pay, feed, and transport thirty-two women for hop picking. I know they were women because Silas lists the entry for the cost of feeding them as boarding “pickers + men,” the men being those who were hired to pull hop poles and tend the boxes.

Pickers were essential to the profitability of the hop-growing enterprise, and wives like Mary Ann were essential to the success of the picking because of the quantity of work required to host all those people—they provided the “room and good board” necessary to attract the right quantity and quality of pickers. The Seymours hosted hop pickers over a decade or more, but the thirty-two pickers of 1867 might have been their biggest year. Mary Ann would have been in charge of the work of hosting them. Daughters Ella and Ida would have been around fourteen and twelve years old, respectively, grown enough to be helpful. Ella accomplished all these chores, and picking and tying hops, with more physical challenges than her sister because of having been born with kyphosis, a strong curvature of her spine…

At some point in the 1860s, Silas even added an extra kitchen onto his house to make space for the cooking required for the annual hop harvest…
I did not expect the Page 99 Test to work so well, but it worked perfectly. Page 99 places women’s work front and center, and we see Ella Seymour, the young hop picker whose diary is a through line of the book, in her own words. The page also reveals one of the book’s major findings, something I did not go looking for but that became unmistakable in the archival record: The work of women, as hop pickers and as the hostesses of those hop pickers, made the hop boom possible, and provided the great breweries of the day with the hops they needed to meet the ever-growing demand for beer.

Throughout this book I try to convey this history both at the ground level, essentially from inside a single farmhouse, and from a birds-eye view. Ella’s diary allows me that glimpse into the farmhouse, and one family’s experience of hop-growing. I pair that unique account with other sources like historical newspapers, and a database I created from the handwritten agricultural census records that includes 4,000 Wisconsin hop farmers. As I write elsewhere in the book, “the small gets us to the big. These figures in the census or the hop reports in newspapers translated into millions of hop cones, each picked by hand from the lengthy bines, and thousands of straw ticks, pillowcases, and dinner plates. Far-off beer drinkers shaped the rhythms of these families and the land around them.” The story of Ella, and of her mother and sister, is also the story of the rise of 19th century beer and its much more famous brewers.
Learn more about Beer Ghosts at the University of Chicago Press website.

-Marshal Zeringue

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Ray E. Boomhower's "Wallace Terry"

Ray E. Boomhower is the acclaimed author of twenty books, including biographies about some of the country’s finest war correspondents such as Ernie Pyle, Richard Tregaskis, and Malcolm W. Browne.

Boomhower applied the “Page 99 Test” to his new book, Wallace Terry: A Reporter's Journey from Selma to Saigon to Bloods, and reported the following:
From page 99:
President Harry S. Truman had attempted to do away with legal segregation in the military by signing Executive Order 9981 on July 26, 1948, inspired in part by the disgust he felt at reports of white racist mobs attacking returning Black veterans. The order offered “equality of treatment and opportunity for all persons in the armed services without regard to race, color, religion or national origin.” By September 1953, as Terry discovered, fewer than 5 percent of Black troops were serving in all-Black units. “For the Black man in the American armed forces, a new chapter appeared to have begun,” he said. To learn more about the change, he traveled to South Vietnam in late April 1967; by this time US troop levels had ballooned to nearly a half million. According to Simmons Fentress, the chief of Time’s bureau in Saigon, the correspondent from the Washington bureau took “less than 24 hours to get over a 24-hour jet ride. Then he swarmed all over the place to plumb the Negro’s feelings about his race and his country, this war and this enemy.”

Because it marked his first venture into a war zone, Terry could not escape a bit of teasing from his colleagues. It fell to Danforth to see that Terry got adjusted to his new surroundings. The correspondents were quartered two doors down from one another at the Continental Palace Hotel. At about two in the morning on his first night in Saigon, Terry woke his friend “to say he had forgotten and drunk a glass of tap water and what should he do,” recalled Danforth. As an antidote to what Danforth considered unsafe drinking water, he recommended a concoction of gin and toothpaste. “Found out the next day he had taken me seriously, and I would have felt pretty bad about that except Wally said it helped relax him,” said Danforth.
Surprisingly, the Page 99 Test works well for giving readers insight into Wallace Terry’s introduction into a conflict that shaped his subsequent life and journalism career—the Vietnam War and Black fighting men’s role on behalf of the U.S. government that sent them thousands of miles from home.

In early 1967 Terry suggested that the magazine do a cover article about Black soldiers fighting in Vietnam. Richard Clurman, Time’s chief of correspondents, called Terry to ask him to fly to Vietnam to help with the story. Terry accepted the assignment, believing that the attention President Lyndon Johnson had given to civil rights and his Great Society programs had been overtaken by a fixation about Vietnam. “I was losing a great story on the homefront to a greater story on the battlefront,” Terry observed.

The cover article, which ran in the magazine’s May 26, 1967, issue, pointed out that for the first time in the country’s history, Black soldiers were “fully integrated in combat, fruitfully employed in positions of leadership, and fiercely proud of their performance.” It seemed as if the U.S. military stood as a shining example when it came to race relations. “It was our first fully integrated war,” Terry observed. “It was democracy in a foxhole—the same mud, the same blood.”

Impressed by Terry’s work, Clurman asked him to return to Vietnam for a two-year stint in Time’s Saigon bureau, working as its deputy chief. Terry quickly accepted the assignment, as Vietnam represented “the biggest story in the world. And also in the back of my mind, I thought that I would write a book.” The correspondent’s two years overseas became “the most exhilarating and exciting years” of his life. “Maybe I got a rush from the danger and from the excitement,” Terry said years after his overseas assignment ended. “I went to where the action was because I felt that’s the only way I could fully tell the story.”

Terry learned that racial relations among American troops in Vietnam had deteriorated from the hopeful story Time had published just a year before. After traveling all over the country, from the demilitarized zone to the Mekong Delta, interviewing American forces, Terry saw that the gung-ho professional soldiers who had volunteered for service early in the war had been superseded by draftees who were much more cynical. “Replacing the careerists were black draftees, many just steps removed from marching in the Civil Rights Movement or rioting in the rebellions that swept the urban ghettos from Harlem to Watts,” Terry observed. “All were filled with a new sense of black pride and purpose.”

These soldiers, who called themselves “Bloods” and lionized Malcolm X, Stokely Carmichael, and Huey Newton, were more willing to question the American presence in the war. As his Time article, “Black Power in Viet Nam,” pointed out, there were more incitements from white soldiers, including Confederate flags displayed on trucks and barracks, cross burnings, and Ku Klux Klan costumes. In response, said Terry, African American troops “raised their fists in black power salutes, had their handshakes, flew red, black and green liberation colors in battle and protected each other against racism.”

After returning to the United States, Terry endured more than a decade worth of challenges until, finally, in 1984, he was able to capture in print the story of the Black soldiers, Marines, sailors, and airmen he had encountered in Vietnam with his oral history Bloods: An Oral History of the Vietnam War by Black Veterans, published in 1984. What touched Terry the most was the reaction to his book from Vietnam veterans. “One black soldier I talked to called me a ‘Blood,” he reported. “He said I’d become one of them.”
Follow Ray E. Boomhower on Instagram and Threads.

The Page 99 Test: Richard Tregaskis.

The Page 99 Test: The Ultimate Protest.

--Marshal Zeringue

Monday, November 9, 2026

Martin Williams's "The Nile Revealed"

Martin Williams is professor emeritus and adjunct professor of earth sciences at the University of Adelaide. His many books include When the Sahara Was Green: How Our Greatest Desert Came to Be; Nile Waters, Saharan Sands: Adventures of a Geomorphologist at Large; and The Nile Basin: Quaternary Geology, Geomorphology, and Prehistoric Environments.

He applied the "Page 99 Test" to his new book, The Nile Revealed: A Deep History of Earth’s Longest River, with the following results:
Page 99 briefly mentions some of the stages in human cultural evolution.

Page 99 is the start of the introduction to Part IV of The Nile Revealed entitled "Human Adaptations to the Nile." It provides a partial summary of some of the main stages in human cultural history, starting with the Early Stone Age. There is no mention on page 99 of the Nile, so that this page only offers a glimpse into one of the many topics covered in this book.

The Nile Revealed: A Deep History of Earth's Longest River explores the many ways in which the Nile and its major tributaries have influenced the plants, animals and human societies dependent on the Nile from earliest times until the present, and concludes with an assessment of how the Nile might respond to future change.
Visit Martin Williams's website.

The Page 99 Test: When the Sahara Was Green.

--Marshal Zeringue

Sunday, November 8, 2026

Jack Turner's "Die Your Own Death"

Jack Turner is professor of political science at the University of Washington, author of Awakening to Race: Individualism and Social Consciousness in America, and coeditor of African American Political Thought: A Collected History.

He applied the “Page 99 Test” to his latest book, Die Your Own Death: Walt Whitman’s Existential Democracy, and shared the following:
Page 99 is the first page of the book’s acknowledgements. It thanks teachers who taught me political theory and American literature, making special mention of Amherst College English professor, Barry O’Connell. It also thanks close friends, departmental colleagues, and the funder of an academic leave.

Page 99 would not give readers a good sense of the content of the book, but it would throw lights on its origins. I address those origins in the Preface. Coincidentally, the first page of the Preface is page ix: “In 1996, when I was a junior at Amherst College, I took a course called ‘American Literature in the Age of Democracy’ and did my first serious reading of Walt Whitman. . . . At the end of the course, the instructor—Barry O’Connell—had us read Democratic Vistas (1871) and it was there that I felt reborn. . . . Here was a book that spoke of democracy not just in political or moral terms, but in existential terms. The word ‘existential’ appears nowhere in Democratic Vistas, but it popped into my twenty-one-year-old head as I read the book’s pages. . . . This book is my attempt—thirty years after I started reading [Whitman]—to commit myself to an interpretation and to explain why I have found the word ‘existential’ an apt descriptor of Whitman’s democratic thought.”

So though the Page 99 Test does not work, the page ix test does. Connecting page 99 and ix, eerily, are the book’s two mentions of O’Connell. Let me conclude by quoting from the paragraph spanning pages ix and x, which provides a nice summary of the book: “Whitman puts death at the center of his vision of democratic citizenship. He hopes that citizens of the newly emergent US democracy in the mid-nineteenth century can gain philosophical confidence on questions of God and death to the same degree that they have gained political confidence on lawmaking and rule. . . . Where Whitman goes further than either Emerson or Thoreau is in the tenacity with which he puts death at the center of the quest for philosophical authority. Citizens must confront death without leaning on orthodox religion. They must make sense of it on naturalistic terms. Whitman offers ways for citizens to interpret death—and reduce their fear of it—outside the traditional Christian worldview. In so doing, he aims to foster a more general acceptance of mortal finitude and vulnerability. Such acceptance, Whitman thought, strengthens freedom and equality.”
Learn more about Die Your Own Death at the Princeton University Press website.

--Marshal Zeringue

Friday, November 6, 2026

Mike Jay's "Wireheads"

Mike Jay is a celebrated historian of science, medicine, and culture. He is the author of acclaimed books including Free Radicals, Mescaline, and Psychonauts, described by Michael Pollan as “easily the most interesting work of psychedelic history I’ve read in years.”

Jay applied the “Page 99 Test” to his new book, Wireheads: An Unnatural History of Technology in the Brain, and reported the following:
Page 99 of Wireheads narrates the arrival of the ‘sexual revolution’ in late 1950s USA: the Kinsey reports, the selling of sex in advertising and consumer culture, and the feminist response in Betty Friedan’s The Feminist Mystique.

At first glance, page 99 is not typical of a book about technology in the brain: the previous half-dozen pages have described the psychologist James Olds’ discovery in 1954 that introducing electric wires into a particular site in the brains of lab rats seemed to stimulate a ‘pleasure centre’ that made them repeat the experience compulsively.

On the other hand, it does give an accurate sense of the book as a cultural history, which places scientific discoveries in a broader cultural context, in which science and society are constantly in dialogue.

The discovery of the ‘pleasure centre’ is a good example of this dialogue. The idea was held up as a cautionary tale of the dangers to which a sexualised, amoral and hedonistic society might lead. Futurologists such as Arthur C. Clarke and Isaac Asimov argued that it was an existential threat to civilisation; the scenario became a standard trope in science fiction stories, and philosophers debated whether plugging directly into the brain’s pleasure centre would generate a meaningful experience.

But the rapid advance of neuroscience soon made these speculations redundant. The discovery of neurotransmitters such as dopamine and serotonin led to a new model of the brain in which there is no specific ‘pleasure centre’ but a complex system of chemically mediated pathways, and pleasure emerges from a dispersed network of ‘hedonic hotspots’.

The ’pleasure centre’ was a flawed scientific theory that struck a cultural nerve and took on a life of its own.
Visit Mike Jay's website.

The Page 99 Test: Mescaline.

--Marshal Zeringue

Thursday, November 5, 2026

M. X. Mitchell's "Unsettling Sovereignty"

M. X. Mitchell is an assistant professor in the federated department of history at the New Jersey Institute of Technology and Rutgers Newark.

She applied the "Page 99 Test" to her new book, Unsettling Sovereignty: International Law, Nuclear Weapons, and US Extraterritorial Power in Postwar Oceania, with the following results:
Imagine that a foreign country has colonized your homeland and begun using parts of your lands and waters to stage nuclear detonations. Now imagine that an explosion went terribly awry, contaminating land, sea, and air and sickening hundreds of your people. Where would you go to seek help? This is the situation in which Marshall Islanders found themselves in 1954.

Marshallese politicians turned to the United Nations Trusteeship Council, which was tasked with oversight of US colonialism in their homelands. Page 99 of my book transports readers to the United Nations headquarters in New York city, where Trusteeship Council representatives from India, Syria, Haiti, El Salvador, the Republic of China, the USSR, Australia, New Zealand, France, Belgium, the United Kingdom, and the United States considered how to respond to a Marshallese petition seeking to halt nuclear blasting in their archipelago.

The Marshallese petition was morally powerful, but legally weak. Although one of its authors, Dwight Heine, elegantly presented the petition’s requests to the Trusteeship Council, the Marshall Islands’ status as a US-governed, UN “strategic” trusteeship, limited Islanders’ possibilities for further action. Because the archipelago was part of a US dependency and not an independent member state of the UN, Islanders could neither raise resolutions there nor file lawsuits at its International Court of Justice. For the petition to have legal purchase, a UN member state would have to take up Islanders’ cause.

The Indian delegation, led by lawyer V. K. Krishna Menon, stepped up, presenting a carefully and narrowly drawn resolution to refer the question of the legality of nuclear blasting in a trust territory to the International Court of Justice. Amid Cold War tensions, the United States delegation had expected that Soviet representatives would seize on the Marshallese petition for political gain. They even thought a neutralist state like India might take some action. But they had not foreseen this legalistic tack. They feared that a narrow, legally-focused resolution could more easily gain support than a political broadside. Characterizing India’s move as “clever and subtly vicious,” they scrambled to muster lawyers and formulate a response.

The page ends on a cliff-hanger: What will the United States do? How will other states respond? And how will the outcome affect Marshall Islanders’ search for justice?

Page 99 encapsulates several core questions I explore throughout the book: Who had a voice in international politics after World War II? What were the affordances and constraints of various forms of sovereignty and dependency? How did peoples subjected to colonialism assert their sovereignty and make themselves heard? What kinds of power did legal claims and arguments generate and what were their limitations?

This page begins to unfold the peculiar legal conundrum faced by residents of the US-governed UN Trust Territory of the Pacific Islands: Sovereignty over their ancestral lands and waters had been so ambiguously divided between the US and UN, that it was unclear whether their grievances against US rule could be adjudicated in any forum. As page 99 shows, their rights in the United Nations were limited to petitioning in the Trusteeship Council. States like India could and did stand in, but they often did so for their own reasons. So while petitioning was a politically powerful tactic, it did not result in an international trial.

The rest of the book explores how Islanders and their allies marshaled legal claims and arguments about US nuclear blasting to political advantage, both in negotiations and in US and Trust Territory courts from the 1950s through the 1980s. It is a story of creative legal maneuvering, false starts, and, ultimately, some stunning reversals.

Not every argument or claim was successful—at least if measured through court wins and losses—but all of them mattered. To find out why, pick up the book, journey with me to beautiful archipelagoes in the north central Pacific Ocean, and follow Marshall Islanders to the United Nations and beyond as they challenged US power and forged their postcolonial sovereignty.
Visit M. X. Mitchell's website.

--Marshal Zeringue

Tuesday, November 3, 2026

Emily G. Shanahan's "Penelope and Her Maids"

Emily G. Shanahan holds a PhD in Classics from Cornell University. She is currently a Solmsen Fellow at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.

She applied the “Page 99 Test” to her new book, Penelope and Her Maids, and shared the following:
From page 99:
On the other hand, the stranger, regardless of whether he is or is not Odysseus, will hear her criticism of their behavior and hopefully understand that she is not fond of these men. Some scholars argue that Penelope’s trick will be obvious to Odysseus, if he gave Penelope no such instruction to get remarried once Telemachus was of age—which would explain why Penelope has never mentioned any such instruction from him before this moment (Büchner 1940, 141; Winkler 1990, 147). Finally, given his own tendency to deceive others, Odysseus ought to respect the trick and appreciate the material gain from it: a woman after his own heart. Odysseus reacts positively to her scheme (18.281–83):
ὣς φάτο· γήθησεν δὲ πολύτλας δῖος Ὀδυσσεύς,
οὕνεκα τῶν μὲν δῶρα παρέλκετο, θέλγε δὲ θυμόν
μειλιχίοις ἐπέεσσι, νόος δέ οἱ ἄλλα μενοίνα.

So she spoke, and much suffering, godlike Odysseus smiled,
Because she drew gifts from them, and charmed their heart
With sweet words, but her mind wanted other things.
What a riddling passage, decontextualized! Page 99 is the second-to-last page of Chapter 4, “Penelope’s Suspicion,” and contains analysis of a scene quoted just prior. In this passage, I follow in the work of scholars such as Philip Harsh (1950) and John Winkler (1990) in theorizing that Penelope may suspect that the mysterious stranger who has just arrived at the palace could be her own husband in disguise. She speaks in a code she trusts him to understand—which he does, based on his positive reaction in the lines quoted above. I think the Page 99 Test would likely lead a reader of the book astray, both because we are forced to interpret Odysseus’ reaction to an unknown event (who are “these men,” and what was “Penelope’s trick”?), and because this analysis speaks to the innovations of others more than my own. My main argument, that Penelope is often reacting to the latent threat of gendered violence and maintains constant risk-mitigation strategies against her aggressive suitors, does not appear here.

There is one way in which this page is, however, representative of the wider book. I work very closely with the text of the Odyssey, quoting, translating, and analyzing approximately 750 lines of the original Greek. These passages are treated in order, so we can see all of Penelope’s statements and decisions in the context of what came before, almost like a running commentary. To me, this seems like the most natural way to assess character and motivation, but it is not, in fact, how previous works tend to be organized; see for example the works of Nancy Felson (1994), Marilyn Katz (1991), and Ioanna Papadopoulou-Belmehdi (1994). My hope, though, is that readers will be able to enjoy the excitement and buildup of the Odyssey’s narrative progression as they ponder questions of psychological motivation, social dynamics, and Homeric scholarship itself.
Learn more about Penelope and Her Maids at the Cornell University Press website.

--Marshal Zeringue

Monday, November 2, 2026

Derek A. Ide's "Ghosts of Bandung"

Derek A. Ide is Visiting Assistant Professor of History at Grand Valley State University and a historian of the Cold War, the Global South, and anticolonialism.

He applied the “Page 99 Test” to his new book, Ghosts of Bandung: Black Power and Palestine in the Global Cold War, and reported the following:
From page 99:
Whatever the flaws in his account, this description was an accurate reflection of CONEFO and its objectives. Sukarno, Aidit, and the PRC’s leaders all envisioned CONEFO as a viable alternative to the United Nations. All anti-imperialist forces, from “fellow travelers” to progressive friends in the First World, would find a home there. It goes without saying that the Palestine Liberation Organization, and its composite parties that emerged in succeed­ing years, would have been represented. And certainly, organizations like the Black Panther Party in the US—founded just months after CONEFO’s inaugural session scheduled in August 1966—would have been given space at CONEFO.

But these grandiose visions of a Third World competitor to the UN were crushed under Suharto’s military boot. Burgeoning national liberation movements, especially emergent but geographically diffuse movements like Black Power and the Palestinian revolution, had lost what had promised to be a vital political and institutional home. While the Panthers and Palestinians would, at various junctures, attempt to use the United Nations as a tool to further their objectives, the limitations of the UN—the same institution that sanctioned the Nakba in 1948—became clearer by the day.
This selection, found on page 99 of Ghosts of Bandung, captures the heart and essence of my book. When, as a young graduate student, I set out to write a book tracing the histories that bound Black Power and the Palestinian Revolution, I had no idea I would one day be writing about Indonesia. I had no idea that “Bandung” would appear in the title, nor that Sukarno’s countenance would grace the front cover.

But as I researched this book – my first academic work – it became clear to me that the timelines of Black Power and Palestine were too closely synchronized. While other scholars had demonstrated that both movements shared a verbiage and vision, the rise of fall of these movements in constellation suggested far more was at play. I had yet to discover the missing piece of that puzzle. The archives led me, by happenstance, to the Conference of the New Emerging Forces (CONEFO). And boy what a missing piece of the puzzle it turned out to be!

CONEFO, in all its forgotten glory, completed the story I set out to tell. Indonesian president Sukarno declared 1964 the “Year of Living Dangerously.” A year before that, in 1963, he had launched his alternative to the Olympics, the “Games of the New Emerging Forces,” or GANEFO. And in January of 1965 he withdrew Indonesia as a member of the United Nations. It was the first – and last – time that a nation has willingly withdrawn from the UN. He planned his own United Nations – CONEFO -- based in Jakarta and emanating in the Global South. It is my contention that had CONEFO not been violently destroyed in the U.S.-backed military coup of October 1965, we would be living in the very different world today.

The book, ultimately, it about that lost future. I hope Ghosts of Bandung will resuscitate this buried past not only for what might have been, but what might yet still be.
Learn more about Ghosts of Bandung at the University of California Press website.

--Marshal Zeringue

Saturday, October 31, 2026

danah boyd's "Data Are Made, Not Found"

danah boyd is the Geri Gay Professor of Communication at Cornell University, where she works on topics at the intersection of technology and society. She is also the founder of the research institute Data & Society and the author of It's Complicated: The Social Lives of Networked Teens.

boyd applied the "Page 99 Test" to her latest book, Data Are Made, Not Found: A Story of Politics, Power, and the Civil Servants Who Saved the US Census, with the following results:
Flip to page 99 and you’re immediately greeted with a battle at the heart of the book. The first two sentences remind you of the high stakes surrounding the census - and why President Trump was determined to ensure that the Census Bureau delivered the data on the statutory deadline, despite the massive disruptions introduced by the Covid-19 pandemic. “If the data were delivered on December 31, he would be president, regardless of whether or not he was reelected. But if Trump lost his bid for reelection— and census data were not delivered until after inauguration day in January 2021— he would not be in control of apportionment.”

As the page unfolds, many key characters who appear throughout the book make an appearance, vocalizing their struggle to deliver on the President’s requirements. We get to hear from the man in charge of the 2020 census - Al Fontenot - as he delivers the orders to his team. He is quoted as saying “We don’t have an option now. We were told to put together a plan that would allow us to finish on time.” And then we get to dive into the headspace of the group as a whole, pulled from multiple interviews. “Despite their misgivings, the team took their orders and started to pivot accordingly.”

The last paragraph on the page provides insight into the importance of the earlier dialogue and documented decision-making - as well as the civil servants’ commitment to doing “the impossible,” which is a theme throughout the book. “Time is not nearly as malleable as politicians seemed to believe. Fontenot’s team delivered an August replan, but not without serious doubt.”

Page 99 reflects the ethnographic detail, rich storytelling, and analysis that is woven throughout Data Are Made, Not Found. It also showcases one of the book’s core arguments. The book argues that politicians are playing a game of “Jenga politics,” taking out wooden pieces of the administrative state and adding pressure on top. Unlike the playful version, where everyone laughs when the tower collapses, the consequences of Jenga politics are the collapse of our democracy. Civil servants try to prevent the Jenga tower from falling, but they are struggling to protect democracy’s data. Page 99 is a great example of how civil servants at the Census Bureau are pushed into a corner to appease partisan interests, Constitutional requirements be damned.
Visit danah boyd's website.

--Marshal Zeringue

Thursday, October 29, 2026

Sarah Marsh's "Novel Constitutions and the Making of Race"

Sarah Marsh is Associate Professor of English at Seton Hill University. A scholar of anglophone literature and culture of the long eighteenth century, she focuses on the western Atlantic histories of race, slavery, and antislavery. Her work explores how eighteenth-century writing confronted the moral, spiritual, and political crises of human slavery, and how literary forms helped shape emerging ideas about freedom, equality, personhood, and human flourishing.

Marsh applied the “Page 99 Test” to her new book, Novel Constitutions and the Making of Race: A Literary and Legal History of Slavery in the Anglophone Atlantic, 1688-1818, and shared the following:
Page 99 of Novel Constitutions and the Making of Race opens a section titled “The Interesting Narrative and the Rise of Transatlantic Abolition,” which sets the scene for Olaudah Equiano’s appeal to the British Crown for the abolition of slavery. It begins:
When Equiano was writing in the late 1780s, the British public’s serious engagement with Parliament on the question of Britain’s role in the transatlantic slave system was still less than a decade old. As Christopher Leslie Brown has shown, the first known petition to Parliament on the question of the slave trade was submitted in June of 1783, signed by 273 Quakers. The Quakers found it their “religious duty to lay the suffering situation” of enslaved Africans before the House of Commons “as a subject loudly calling for the humane interposition of the Legislature.” The Quakers continued by voicing their “regret, that a nation professing the Christian faith, should so far counteract the principles of humanity and justice, as by cruel treatment of this oppressed race, to fill their minds with prejudices against the mild and beneficent doctrines of the Gospel.” The Commons, which in the previous century had appealed to ideals of Christian benevolence and generosity to fence in the royal prerogative of the Stuarts, were now appealed to by members of the British public to curb the absolute power of colonial slaveholders.
This page passes the Page 99 Test with something like flying colors. The last sentence of the paragraph above is a solid recapitulation of the book's central finding: Novel Constitutions argues that racial slavery in the English Atlantic, and the concept of race itself, grew out of seventeenth-century England’s great constitutional struggle between the divine right of kings and the immemorial liberties of the English people's ancient constitution. In the colonies, English slaveholders claimed over other human beings the absolute power that people and Parliament had refused to the Stuart kings. By 1783, Britons had begun to ask Parliament to fence in slaveholding planters and slave traders as it had once fenced in the Crown.

This page also pretty well encapsulates the book’s methodology of reading literary and legal texts together: page 99 of Novel Constitutions includes a Quaker petition, a treaty, and a reference to Defoe’s Robinson Crusoe, whose title character goes outside of royal power to become a slaveholder in his own right. Further, the Quaker petition on page 99 conceives of human slavery as not only a crime against humanity, but a crime against God; in this way, the page points toward Novel Constitution's larger project of explaining why we call racial slavery the "original sin" of the American republic.
Learn more about Novel Constitutions and the Making of Race at the Oxford University Press website.

--Marshal Zeringue

Tuesday, October 27, 2026

Michael B. Cosmopoulos's "Rediscovering Homer"

Michael B. Cosmopoulos is the Hellenic Government-Karakas Foundation Professor in Greek Studies at the University of Missouri-St. Louis. A fellow of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences and the Royal Society of Canada, he is the author of numerous books on the archaeology and history of ancient Greece, most recently the award-winning The World of Homer: Archaeology, Social Memory, and the Emergence of Greek Epic Poetry.

Cosmopoulos applied the “Page 99 Test” to his new book, Rediscovering Homer: The Human Experience in the Odyssey and the Iliad, and reported the following:
Page 99 of Rediscovering Homer falls in Chapter 4, “War and Violence,” in a section devoted to violence and trauma and presents two particularly powerful scenes from the Iliad. In the first, the Greek and Trojan armies clash in battle, their collision compared by Homer to two mountain torrents crashing together, and a warrior is killed when a spear pierces his forehead. In the second, warriors struggle over the corpse of Sarpedon, their weapons clashing amid blood and dust. Homer compares them to flies swarming around pails of milk, an image that strips the battle of any semblance of heroic glory.

Does the Page 99 Test work?

The Page 99 Test works well for this book, although the page represents only one aspect of its broader subject. One of my principal arguments is that the Iliad and the Odyssey are much more than stories of heroic adventures, because they preserve universal and profoundly human experiences: the experiences of people who lived through war, violence, loss, displacement, and the difficult process of rebuilding their lives.

We tend to associate Homer with heroic ideals, courage, honor, and military glory, but the reality is that the poems also present a different picture, one of suffering, grief, fear, and the devastating consequences of violence. Page 99 captures precisely this tension between the traditional glorification of war and the harsh realities of human experience.

This perspective is also deeply personal. My parents lived through the devastation of World War II and the Greek Civil War, and their experiences shaped my understanding of the lasting effects of violence and loss.

The book explores the full range of human experience, from family relationships and social bonds to political power, economic struggles, religion, and the choices we make in the face of adversity. At the heart of the book is the journey through life, with all its challenges, losses, and uncertainties, a journey embodied by Odysseus, whose story connects the two epics.

The Iliad portrays the devastation of war and its consequences for individuals and communities, while the Odyssey turns to the equally difficult struggle to survive, return home, and rebuild a life after loss. Together, the poems speak to experiences that remain fundamental to the human condition, which is why they continue to resonate with us nearly three thousand years after they began to take shape.
Visit Michael B. Cosmopoulos's website.

--Marshal Zeringue

Monday, October 26, 2026

Bryant Simon's "For Customers Only"

Bryant Simon is the Laura H. Carnell Professor of History and the academic chair of the honors program at Temple University. He is the author of The Hamlet Fire: The Tragic Story of Cheap Food, Cheap Government, and Cheap Lives, as well as Everything but the Coffee: Learning about America from Starbucks. He is a regular guest on the History Channel and a contributor to outlets like the New York Daily News, Washington Post, and Philadelphia Inquirer.

Simon applied the Ford Madox Ford-inspired "Page 99 Test" to his latest book, For Customers Only: Public Bathrooms and the Making of American Inequality, with the following results:
Page 99 of my new book, For Customers Only: Public Bathrooms and the Making of American Inequality, lands readers right smack in the middle of the murder investigation of Edgar L. Eckert, an assistant treasurer for a high-end men’s clothing story in mid-town Manhattan.

And it lands them right smack in the middle of a key transition in the book’s trajectory.

On a cool mid-May night in1936, after dinner with a colleague, Eckert, fifty-fours years old, married, and wearing a tailored suit, a gold ring and gold watch, walked towards Times Square. By then, the Bronx resident had lived in the city for almost four decades.

Still, he asked a trio of men how to get to the well-marked subway station a block or two away. They pointed him in the right direction and then followed him into the station, down onto the platform, and then up to a mezzanine and what was later described as an “out of the way” public bathroom.

Just after 2AM, a janitor found Eckert slumped on the bathroom floor, unable to speak and barely conscious. He died a few minutes later.

The police launched a manhunt for the killers and puzzled over Eckert’s movements. That’s what I wrote about on page 99. New York City detectives knew right away that this was a robbery. Eckert’s ring, watch, and wallet were gone, but they also wondered about the “queer” dimensions of the crime. Were the three men hustlers? Had Eckert lured them into a public bathroom for a quick sexual encounter before heading back to his modest outer borough home?

From the time that the first public bathrooms opened in New York in the late 19th Century, men seeking sex with other men (and male presenting people) met at the sinks and in the stalls. The police were alarmed and tried to better surveille these places. Along with allies on the city council, they put laws on the book that outlawed oral sex. But still men engaged in sexual encounters with other men in the city’s public bathrooms and this private act in public disturbed authorities.

After Ecket was killed, New York decided on a new tactic. City officials closed the out-of-the-way bathroom where Eckert was slain and a few others. The idea was to eliminate this place for illicit sex, to take it off the map, and to do what surveillance and arrests could not do, disappear those interested in sex in public from view.

This official move represented a massive change in bathroom governance. The initial public bathrooms were opened to expand the public sphere, to make the city bigger and more accessible to more people. From the 1930s forward, local leaders shifted gears and tried to narrow the public by closing public bathrooms – this happened after segregation broke down, this happened when homelessness came into view, and this is happening now to disappear trans and gender queer people, and this is the action unfolding on page 99 of my book.

Ford Madox Ford was right!
Learn more about For Customers Only at the University of Chicago Press website.

--Marshal Zeringue

Saturday, October 24, 2026

Eric Caplan's "When Healing Harms"

Eric Caplan is author of Mind Games: American Culture and the Birth of Psychotherapy and recipient of the University of Chicago's Quantrell Award for Excellence in Undergraduate Teaching.

He applied the “Page 99 Test” to his latest book, When Healing Harms: The Doctor Who Put a Hospital on Trial―and the Case That Shook Psychiatry, and shared the following:
Page 99 of When Healing Harms finds Dr. Raphael Osheroff trying to reclaim the life he had left behind ten months earlier. Once a prosperous physician who owned and operated a thriving dialysis practice, Osheroff had spent seven months at Chestnut Lodge, a prestigious psychiatric hospital outside Washington, D.C., where his doctors treated his severe depression with intensive psychotherapy alone. They documented his physical and emotional deterioration in painstaking detail (the relentless pacing, the forty-pound weight loss, the blackened toes) yet refused to prescribe antidepressant medication that might relieve his suffering. He then spent three months at Silver Hill Hospital in Connecticut, where medication and supportive psychotherapy began lifting his depression within weeks.

But his homecoming came with no yellow ribbon tied around an old oak tree. What he returned to was not only an empty house, stripped of its furniture and even its grand piano, but a collapsing marriage and a court order denying him the right to visit his two older sons. Worse still, Dr. Robert Greenspan, his trusted associate and friend, “the brother I never had,” as Osheroff called him, had promised to preserve and protect his medical practice during his hospitalization but had been surreptitiously maneuvering to take it from him. When Osheroff returned to the dialysis center, Greenspan and another colleague refused even to speak with him. Having survived a devastating psychiatric illness, he now faced the loss of the professional life he had spent years building.

The Ford Madox Ford-inspired Page 99 Test works remarkably well for this book, although perhaps not for the most obvious reasons.

When Healing Harms recounts a landmark malpractice case that exposed a profound division within American psychiatry over the treatment of depression. Osheroff’s lawsuit against Chestnut Lodge became a cause célèbre, widely understood as a contest between psychoanalysis and biological psychiatry. At its heart, though, was a simpler question: whether a desperately ill patient had received the standard of care. Its consequences reached far beyond the hearing room, accelerating changes already underway in how America treats mental illness.

The case also raises a question psychiatry has yet to answer. The profession has long held unearned confidence in its theories of both mind and brain. It has given us the Oedipus complex and the chemical imbalance, but not yet the mechanisms that would confirm either. We keep substituting metaphor for mechanism. That need not harm patients, since treatments can work even when we cannot fully explain why. That said, uncertainty is no license to persist in a course of treatment that worsens, rather than relieves, a patient’s suffering. Osheroff’s doctors were so sure of their theory that they interpreted his deterioration as evidence that the treatment was working: he had to get worse before he could get better. When theory becomes dogma, the patient becomes collateral damage.

But the book is also about something more intimate: the distance between medical recovery and personal restoration.

Osheroff eventually prevailed in his legal battle, but vindication was not restoration. His victory could not repair his marriage, restore his bond with his sons, or return the years he believed had been stolen from him. His case became a defining episode in the history of American psychiatry, even as the man at its center struggled to rebuild his life.

Page 99 captures that paradox. Osheroff had recovered from his depression. What he had not recovered was the world he had lost.

Readers can follow each of the book’s notes to the underlying primary sources, wherever the law allows, at whhsources.org.
Visit Eric Caplan's website.

--Marshal Zeringue

Thursday, October 22, 2026

Barbara Young Welke's "Writing with Fire"

Barbara Young Welke is the Distinguished McKnight University Professor of history and law at the University of Minnesota. She is the author of Law and the Borders of Belonging in the Long Nineteenth Century United States and Recasting American Liberty: Gender, Race, Law, and the Railroad Revolution, 1865–1920.

She applied the “Page 99 Test” to her new book, Writing with Fire: The Cowboy Suit Tragedy and the Course of a Life, and reported the following:
From page 99:
On Sunday, April 8, 1945, a double headline spanned the columns of page 1 of the Washington, DC, Times-Herald: “Patton Seizes Nazi Gold Hoard” and “Yanks Smash Japs Naval Power.” But just beneath these headlines, in columns 2 and 3, was an investigative report by Times-Herald reporters Roland Nicholson and Spence Drummond: “D.C. Parents Warned: Inflammable Cowboy Suits Kill One Child Here, Burn 7” and “Fuzzy ‘Chaps’ Flare Like Torches; Stores Are Notified, Probe Launched.” Here was what for so long had been lacking: a story clearly identifying the danger.
Here’s what I like about the Page 99 Test for Writing with Fire: it lands in a chapter about the cowboy suit tragedy. At mid-century, children across the United States suffered burns when their highly inflammable Gene Autry cowboy playsuits caught fire, Americans’ first reckoning with “flammable fabrics.” The history of this tragedy is the heart of the book. One of the questions that troubled me from the start in working on this project was why it had taken so long—close to three years of children across the United States being burned, many dying—before the hazard began to be known for what it was. The Page 99 Test lands in the chapter focused on the role of the press in reinforcing the common-sense narrative that this is what happens when children play with fire, situates readers in the broader World War II context in which this tragedy unfolded; and, just so happens to be the page on which I introduce news stories from DC that identified the dangerously inflammable character of the fuzzy fabric on the chaps of the Gene Autry cowboy suit as the cause of deaths and injuries. As readers later learn, this coverage was key to the first lawsuits brought against Autry and others involved in producing and selling the cowboy suits.

But the test is also misleading. Although the news broke in DC, it did not break elsewhere with the result that children continued to be burned and die. But it’s also misleading because this tragedy is only one of three strands in this braided narrative. Intertwined with the cowboy suit tragedy is a history of the curriculum vitae, the form at the center of academic life. That sounds dry, unrelated, and certainly unexpected. It’s none of these things. It’s here because a traumatic loss in my life—the sudden death of my teenage daughter—led me to question how the CV, as it is colloquially called, claims to represent a life, and yet excludes so much of what gives life meaning, reinforcing norms that ask scholars to distance themselves from their emotions and personal experience in the writing of history and other disciplines. Braided between the two historical strands are letters I wrote my daughter in the year and a half after her death. Together this braided narrative invites readers to think deeply about history and the course of a life.
Learn more about Writing with Fire at the University of Chicago Press website.

--Marshal Zeringue

Wednesday, October 21, 2026

Livia K. Stone's "Without Masters"

Livia K. Stone is Associate Professor of Anthropology at Illinois State University and author of Atenco Lives!: Filmmaking and Popular Struggle in Mexico.

She applied the "Page 99 Test" to her new book, Without Masters: Autogestión, Anarchist Ethics, and Mexico City Punk, with the following results:
Page 99 of Without Masters: Autogestión, Anarchist Ethics, and Mexico City Punk does provide an interesting insight into the book as a whole. It describes a pivotal moment in the recent history of the concept of autogestión (often translated as self-management, or non-hierarchical organization) that the book describes.

From page 99:
The early 1990s saw a proliferation of both anarcho-punk zines and autogestión discourse. The year 1992 was the five-hundred-year anniversary of Columbus's initial (Spain funded) voyage to the Americas, and it spurred a political response across the rapidly increasing number of zines and their increasingly articulate politics that were disgusted by the official events celebrating the anniversary rather than condemning it. While Contraviolencia and Carmelo were early innovators of anarcho-punk zines, after 1992, it would have been difficult to find a punk zine that didn't mix its interviews with bands and concerts announcements with anarchist political essays.
The page goes on to describe that part of the politicization of the punk scene was happening because punks were increasingly hanging out and making their zines at Mexico City’s anarchist library, founded by a man named Ricardo Mestre, who was an exile from the Spanish Civil War earlier in the century. They were becoming acquainted with classical anarchist texts there, but also the library was becoming a social center for producing anarcho-punk publications, including a wealth of zines that formed the basis of this part of the book.

Without Masters overall uses the recent history of autogestión as a window through which to explore some large issues at the intersections of activism and scholarship, including how academics can appropriate activist ideas and how activists can deploy academic ideas. It is a fascinating story of cultural change through time. Although I believe the story of autogestión is a thrilling one in its own right, I think even readers not particularly interested in anarchism, punk, or even Mexico, will find it a compelling story of cultural and political movement through many of the major political moments of the twentieth century: African independence movements of the early 1960s when autogestión emerged, the countercultural and student movements of the late 1960s and 1970s where it was used as a slogan, punk in the 1970s and 1980s when it transformed meanings, Zapatismo and the anti-neoliberal movements of the 1990s that popularized the term and attached it to indigenous organizing, and the turn towards ideas of the local and sustainable in the 2000s where it became a foundational principle for small collectives.
Learn more about Without Masters at the Duke University Press website.

--Marshal Zeringue

Monday, October 19, 2026

Kevin Waite's "The Boundless Biddy Mason"

Kevin Waite is Anne Stark Watson and Chester Watson Distinguished Professor of History at the University of Texas at Dallas. His first book, West of Slavery, won the 2022 Wiley-Silver Prize and was shortlisted for three other awards, including the Lincoln Prize. His writing appears in The Atlantic, the Los Angeles Times, The Washington Post, Slate, National Geographic, and The New Republic. Waite moonlights in the TV and film industry, most recently as the writer and producer of a six-episode docuseries on the American Revolution for National Geographic and Disney+.

He applied the “Page 99 Test” to his latest book, The Boundless Biddy Mason: An Odyssey from Slavery to Freedom Across the American West, and shared the following:
Oh great. This section. That’s what I thought as I cracked open my book to page 99 and confronted a particularly stubborn passage. There weren’t many, if any, sections that I rewrote as many times as I did this one. It describes the various tasks that Biddy Mason performed as an enslaved woman on a remote ranch outside San Bernardino, California in the early 1850s.

Mason had been hauled across the continent on a series of forced migrations – from Georgia to Mississippi to Utah and finally to California – over the preceding years. Although California had technically outlawed slavery in its state constitution, Mason and her daughters continued to labor in bondage for about five years after their arrival in 1851. Her owner, Robert Smith, was by this point the largest slaveholder in the American Far West, with Mason and thirteen others under his control.

What did slavery look like in the free state of California? That’s what this passage attempts to describe. Wheat and dairy, rather than cotton and sugar, dictated the rhythms of the day for enslaved people on Smith’s ranch. Mason probably spent a portion of her day with Smith’s herd of livestock, when she wasn’t otherwise harvesting his fields, cleaning his home, or delivering his neighbors' children. (She was a skilled midwife on top of it all.)

What made this passage particularly difficult to write also makes it representative and illuminating. Mason left no records in her own hand, aside from a few legal documents marked with an “X.” Her story, therefore, must be reconstructed from a fragmentary archival base, often the records of those who viewed her as property, not a person. To avoid scrutiny in an ostensibly free state, California slaveholders rarely described their Black laborers in any detail. This passage, then, is stitched together from the observations of others – often hastily rendered in letters or diaries – as well as the tithing records of Robert Smith, a member of the LDS Church.

The aim of this passage is to render visible what others sought to hide. And that, in effect, is the aim of the book as a whole: to illuminate the life of a remarkable woman, who survived a 3,000-mile forced migration, helped launch the largest freedom suit in the history of the American West, and eventually built an empire in Los Angeles real estate that made her the 19th-century equivalent of a multi-millionaire.
Learn more about The Boundless Biddy Mason at the University of California Press website.

--Marshal Zeringue

Saturday, October 17, 2026

Scot McFarlane's "The River That Made Texas"

Scot McFarlane is a river historian and founder of the Oxbow History Company.

He applied the “Page 99 Test” to his new book, The River That Made Texas: A Forgotten History of the Trinity, and reported the following:
From page 99:
A map made by Riché in 1899 highlights the unique emphasis placed on Trinity navigation across Texas (fig. 8.6). Riché created it for a different, smaller Texas river survey of the San Bernard River that he submitted to Congress. In the catalog description of the New York Public Library where this map is now archived, there is no mention of the Trinity, but it stands out nonetheless. The map shows all the Texas rivers that flow into the Gulf of Mexico. The rivers are color coded, with blue indicating existing opportunities to navigate and red for river sections where proposed improvements could make the river navigable. Along the coast, most waterways have a mix of red and blue. The Trinity is coded as already navigable up to Liberty, and then from there to Dallas it is colored red. Riché marked no other rivers in this manner, and the result makes the map appear as though a blood-colored gash runs across the state—as if the blood from Fort Worth’s slaughterhouses dyed the Trinity.
Also included on page 99 is an image of the river with this caption: "This image from the 1899 Army Corps of Engineers survey captures three of the key challenges of navigation: low water, snags, and a logjam."

Before I started writing The River That Made Texas, my friend and mentor Matt Klingle had told me about the 99 page test, so I actually began writing the book in the middle with this very test in mind, though where I began writing does not overlap perfectly with page 99 in the final published version.

This excerpt highlights the Trinity River's unique place in Texas history as the state's most navigable river and the one that boosters and engineers dreamed of making even more navigable all the way to Dallas and Fort Worth. This section of the book explains how men like Riché overlooked the communities that already called the river home downstream of Dallas. Essentially they treated it as a wilderness in need of development when in fact it was a vital home. Though this particular section does not share the story of the Trinity River's people, its themes and symbolism are at the core of the book when I wrote how Trinity's representation on the map makes it look "as though a blood-colored gash runs across the state." Funny enough, the book's blurb from Karl Jacoby echoes this line perfectly: "Scot McFarlane shows how the Trinity River cuts like a knife through the heart of Texas history."
Visit Scot McFarlane's website.

--Marshal Zeringue

Thursday, October 15, 2026

Samantha Barbas's "Hate Speech"

Samantha Barbas is a legal and cultural historian and the author of several books on media history and legal history topics, with a focus on journalism, privacy, defamation, and the First Amendment.

She is a Professor of Law at the University at Iowa, and has a Ph.D. in history from the University of California, Berkeley, and a J.D. from Stanford Law School. She is the recipient of a National Endowment for the Humanities Public Scholar Award.

Barbas applied the "Page 99 Test" to her new book, Hate Speech: The Legal and Cultural History of an American Dilemma, with the following results:
Page 99 describes the case of Kunz v. New York, from 1951. The case involved a Baptist minister who made speeches containing vile invective against Catholics and Jews and was convicted for making a speech on the streets of New York without a permit. Kunz had been denied a permit because of a flood of complaints to authorities about his speeches. The Supreme Court struck down the city ordinance, stating that it violated the First Amendment because it gave authorities the power to control, in advance, the ability to speak freely on religious subjects.

Justice Robert Jackson fired off an indignant dissent. He characterized the minister’s hateful statements – especially in light of the Holocaust – as fighting words, akin to physical blows. He believed that a discretionary permit system like New York’s could protect a city against “fanatics who take possession of its streets to hurl into its crowds defamatory epithets that hurt like rocks.”

Page 99 captures the tension at the heart of the book. For over a hundred years, Americans have been torn between the importance of protecting against the violence and inequality that can stem from hate speech, and, at the same time, upholding the freedom of speech guaranteed by the First Amendment. By the early 1950s, the Supreme Court was moving in a speech-protective direction, issuing rulings that cast doubt on the validity of restrictions on hate speech. In Terminiello v. Chicago (1949), the Court struck down Chicago’s breach-of-the-peace conviction of an antisemitic speaker. Justice Jackson – who had returned to the Court after serving as lead prosecutor at the Nuremberg Trials – warned in dissent that the Court had overlooked the connections between hate speech and totalitarian takeover and was turning the Bill of Rights into a “suicide pact.”

Jackson lost the fight, and over the next two decades, the Court created a First Amendment jurisprudence that essentially negated the possibility of hate speech laws. Today, there are no “hate speech laws” in America, of the kind that exist in most other countries; hate speech is generally protected by the First Amendment. Although Jackson’s position lost at the Supreme Court, he won in the court of public opinion—he received fan mail and accolades for his “suicide pact” statement.

This dynamic remains: while most Americans support free speech generally, they draw the line at protecting hate speech. There is no more contested free speech idea than “freedom for the thought that we hate.”
Visit Samantha Barbas's website.

The Page 99 Test: Laws of Image.

The Page 99 Test: Newsworthy.

The Page 99 Test: The Rise and Fall of Morris Ernst, Free Speech Renegade.

The Page 99 Test: Actual Malice.

--Marshal Zeringue

Tuesday, October 13, 2026

Lee Alan Dugatkin's "Nary a Horse Left Standing"

Lee Dugatkin is Professor of Biology at the University of Louisville. The author of How to Tame a Fox (and Build a Dog), Power in the Wild, Mr. Jefferson and the Giant Moose, and Principles of Animal Behavior, among other books, he is a fellow in the Animal Behavior Society and has lectured at over 200 universities and museums across the globe. He is a contributor to Scientific American, Psychology Today, and New Scientist.

Dugatkin applied the “Page 99 Test” to his latest book, Nary a Horse Left Standing: How a Nineteenth-Century Epidemic Transformed Medicine, Animal Welfare, and the Modern City, and shared the following:
From page 99 of Nary a Horse Left Standing:
In [Henry] Bergh’s speech to the ASPCA in which he invoked “the tribunal of Eternal Justice” for acts of cruelty against animals, he also tells his fellow members to ask themselves this: “Why should a man . . . who without the least remorse torments and destroys other creatures, hesitate to do the same, after such an apprenticeship, to any human being that happens to stand in the way of his caprices or ambition?” Bergh was convinced such a man would not hesitate and was “persuaded that the obduracy of heart and unrelenting disposition which we discover in some men, is owing in a great measure to the early indulgence of such a disposition towards the inferior animals.
The Page 99 Test for Nary a Horse Left Standing works respectably well for one thread in the book: how a massive 1872 outbreak of horse flu that paralyzed almost every major urban center in North America ushered in a revolution in animal rights, led by Henry Bergh and the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA).

That massive outbreak of horse flu soon was dubbed The Great Epizootic, the animal equivalent of a pandemic. In the fall of 1872, horses were the lifeblood of every metropolis across North America. New York City alone had 38,000, who were the living, breathing engines that powered the city. At least half, and likely more, of those horses were laid up for weeks at a time during The Great Epizootic. Suddenly, the power sources driving fire carts, garbage trucks, hearses and delivery carts that stocked the shelves of everything from thousands of mom and pop stores to the new department stores, were convalescing in stables.

And that was just the tip of the iceberg. Before The Great Epizootic, each day more than 300,000 tickets were sold to ride on streetcars powered by horses. Each of these streetcars transported one or two dozen people to work, to shop or to cultural venues like the newly opened Metropolitan Museum of Art and The American Museum of Natural History.

During The Great Epizootic the number of streetcars riding the inlaid rails of Gotham plummeted. This was in part due to all the sick horses in streetcar company stables, but it was also due to Henry Burgh and the ASPCA’s work to make sure that when avarice owners of these companies tried to force clearly sick horses to work nonetheless, they failed at the opportunity to line their pockets at the expense of those animals.

The goings on of October 30, 1872 provide a snapshot of what became a daily occurrence. That day, in the heat of The Great Epizootic, Bergh and a team from the ASPCA stationed themselves near a switch that allowed streetcars from the Third Avenue streetcar line to move from uptown to downtown tracks. Two policemen stood by to keep order. When a Third Avenue streetcar came along, Bergh and his team forced it to stop and inspected the horses. “Mr. Bergh pointed to the yellow looking noses of the horses,” reported the New York Herald, a paper that had already dubbed Bergh “the great philohippic.” “These animals are too sick to work,” the Herald wrote, quoting Bergh, “take the other track and go back to the stables.”

The next day Bergh was back on the streets, this time where the Bleecker Street streetcar line ran, to inspect more horses. So it went every day during The Great Epizootic, when nary a horse was left standing.
Visit Lee Alan Dugatkin's website.

The Page 99 Test: Power in the Wild.

The Page 99 Test: Dr. Calhoun's Mousery.

--Marshal Zeringue

Monday, October 12, 2026

Leah C. Stokes's "The Carbon Wave"

Leah C. Stokes is Anton Vonk Associate Professor of Environmental Politics at UC Santa Barbara. As a leading climate advocate, she has championed climate policy in the United States at all levels of government and was selected for Time Magazine’s Time100 Next list and Business Insider’s top 30 global climate leaders. A recipient of a Harvard University Radcliffe Fellowship, she is the author of the award-winning Short Circuiting Policy, which was listed as one of the top 5 climate books in 2020 by The New York Times.

Stokes applied the “Page 99 Test” to her new book, The Carbon Wave: A Story of Democracy, Parenthood, and the Race to Protect Our Planet, and reported the following:
From page 99:
The combination of Gina’s bad quote and the delayed bipartisan infrastructure package caused a bunch of senators to begin speaking up more forcefully. Senator Smith stayed on message, arguing her clean electricity program was key. Senator Heinrich said he wouldn’t vote for a package without climate in it, and Senator Wyden agreed. But the idea really caught fire when Senator Markey told The New York Times that he wouldn’t support an infrastructure deal without climate at its center, saying: “No climate, no deal.” Across the climate movement, folks seized on this phrase, making it our rallying cry. We repeated it again and again, putting it on websites, banners, and tweets.”
Page 99 of The Carbon Wave gives the reader a look at one snippet of the long, tumultuous journey that gave way to the Inflation Reduction Act, the largest federal climate package in American history. This moment comes in the Spring of 2021, when President Biden and Senate Majority Leader Schumer are trying to build support for a climate bill–particularly from moderate Senator Joe Manchin–as a bipartisan infrastructure package is simultaneously being negotiated. I’d say this page is largely representative of the broader story for a couple of reasons.

This moment captures one of the book’s central themes, which is that advocacy is a lot like jazz: it’s highly improvisational and unpredictable, and the fight for the IRA was no different. When unexpected challenges or windows of opportunities arose, we pivoted, focusing on how to capitalize on new openings and make progress. If Gina McCarthy (President Biden’s National Climate Advisor) hadn’t had that accidental slip-up, “No Climate, No Deal” would never have taken hold, pressuring the administration and Senate negotiators to continue prioritizing the climate law alongside the bipartisan infrastructure deal.

This passage also highlights how delicate policy making can be: leaders have different priorities and perceptions of what’s important, and seemingly minor errors or misunderstandings can derail the entire process. Exposing readers to tense political moments like this one helps people understand how bills actually become laws, which is often more coordinated and complicated than the Schoolhouse Rock jingle suggests. In reality, government leaders, policy wonks, outside advocates, and everyday people all form an intricate network to set policy goals, maintain public pressure, and negotiate to get a bill across the finish line.
Visit Leah C. Stokes's website.

The Page 99 Test: Short Circuiting Policy.

--Marshal Zeringue